Showing posts with label for your reconsidersation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label for your reconsidersation. Show all posts


For Your Reconsideration: The Monkees - Head


At the start of 1968, The Monkees were one of the most popular bands on the planet, with a top rated television show that provided prime exposure for their music, helping them sell more records in America than any other group except The Beatles.  By the end of the year, the show was cancelled, their music dropped off the charts, and The Monkees were essentially finished as a group (though they continued to drag out their sagging fortunes for a couple of years, with ever-shrinking lineups).  The speed with which this decline took place is pretty staggering, but, in a post-Sgt. Pepper world, the deck was decidedly stacked against the Monkees, with new premiums placed on ideals such as “authenticity” and “adventurousness,” ideals that the public (and the new wave of music critics in particular) thought the Monkees lacked, being “manufactured” by the industry. 
            
The Monkees, understandably, were tiring of these accusations, as they had assumed total control of their work by this point, and had been putting out quality records for years. In reaction to this, they started taking more chances on their show, adding psychedelic elements, as well as having counterculture figures like Frank Zappa appear regularly, which prompted their producers to pull the plug on a show that was starting to outgrow their largely young audience.  With no way to seemingly please either their built-in audience, or the more mature listeners that would never give them a chance, The Monkees decided to blow it out in grand fashion, fashioning a film with the help of producer Bob Rafelson and writer Jack Nicholson, and a soundtrack album to accompany it.  The resulting record, Head, is, like the film itself, absolutely wild.  It’s also completely ahead of its time.
            
Head is, at its heart, a sound collage, conveying the plot of the film in chronological order through the use of dialogue snippets, with the music serving to illuminate the themes on hand. The dialogue is, by turn, faux-profound, satirical, sometimes overwrought, and sometimes hilarious, and completely soaked in psychedelia, a skewed window into The Monkees world at this time.  They address their critics (“Ditty Diego - War Chant”), delve into funny non-sequiturs (“Superstitious,” “Gravy,” containing the immortal line “I’d like a glass of cold gravy with a hair in it, please.”), and engage in hippie mysticism (“Swami-Plus Strings (Ken Thorne). Etc.”)  The scattered nature of Head brings to mind contemporary works by Frank Zappa such as Lumpy Gravy, where dialogue and music work together in a similar manner.
            
The heart of the record, however, lies in its music, which is as scattershot as the dialogue in between, but is infinitely more palatable and engrossing.  “Porpoise Song,” written by Gerry Goffin and Carole King, is the first proper song on Head, an epic psychedelic masterpiece, with towering organ and strings accompanying a mournful, fantastic Micky Dolenz vocal, which is strangely reminiscent of Grace Slick of Jefferson Airplane fame.  It’s one of The Monkees greatest achievements as a band, and stands up to similar epics like “Nights In White Satin.”  Dolenz also shines on another Goffin/King composition, “As We Go Along,” a more low-key folk ballad with gentle acoustic guitar and great instrumental interplay.  These two songs also show how Michael Nesmith, the main creative force in the group, had matured into a great producer, adding the right touches, never going overboard in arrangements, as other groups of that era were guilty of doing. 
            
Nesmith gets to highlight his own songwriting as well with the rollicking “Circle Sky,” a country rock song driven by a fantastic guitar riff and layers of percussion, with cowbell, shakers, and tambourines keeping a tight groove in the midst of its seemingly chaotic production.  It’s his only contribution to Head, but it’s strong, and shows that he had a tighter grip on country rock than several similar acts around this time, including The Byrds, who had put out their seminal Sweetheart Of The Rodeo that same year (on a side note, Nesmith had been doing country rock years before it became popular, at least since “Papa Gene’s Blues,” from The Monkees’ self-titled debut album in 1965, predating the genre‘s emergence by at least three years).
            
Davy Jones also gets his time in the sun, and thankfully avoids falling into his usual habit of putting out sappy, cheesy material.  “Daddy’s Song” is a comical delight, written by Harry Nilsson and performed in the music hall style that The Beatles had popularized with songs like “When I’m Sixty Four.” Jones sells it for all it’s worth, using his theatrical background to give the songs a brassy, Broadway style interpretation.
            
The big surprise of Head, however, is the emergence of Peter Tork as a songwriter of note.  Previously with only a few songs to his name, he provides two songs, both of which are highlights.  Perhaps playing on his Harrisonesque role in the group, his first contribution, “Can You Dig It?” is a full on Indian rocker, with guitars that sound like sitars noodling in the mix, while Dolenz sings in a near drone, helping to sell the contrived hippie clichés contained in the lyrics.  It’s a dark, menacing song propelled by some great guitar and bass interplay.  His other contribution, “Long Title: Do I Have To Do This All Over Again?,” is full-bore acid rock, with Tork himself giving in a convincing vocal, and searing guitar rock providing the icing on one of the Monkees’ hardest rocking songs.
            
So, The Monkees touch on a lot of bases here.  Psychedelia, country rock, music hall…it’s almost a summary of the prevalent musical styles of 1968, and only in six songs.  If that seems a bit far reaching, well, that was the intention anyway. With Head, The Monkees really did blow it out in grand fashion.  And how were they rewarded? With more critical lambasting, this time for both the film and album.  Both flopped miserably.  However, Head lives on as a testament to how out there, almost avant-garde, The Monkees could be when putting their energy into it.  In this instance, they created something that critics never thought they were capable of: art.





For Your Reconsideration: The Beach Boys - Love You


The story of The Beach Boys, and Brian Wilson in particular, post-Pet Sounds is well documented, and does not need to be recounted in great detail here.  However, some context is needed to illuminate the factors that went into the making of this week’s featured album. After attempting a “teenage symphony to God” with the ill-fated SMiLE project, Wilson and the rest of the group entered a murky period of inconsistent recordings, and, in Wilson’s case, erratic behavior caused by a complete nervous breakdown. While their work from Smiley Smile (1967) to Surf’s Up (1972) remains, in this writer’s opinion, wildly underrated, it failed to sell, and soon after the completion of Surf’s Up, Brian Wilson quietly left the fold of The Beach Boys, opting to live in seclusion, rarely leaving bed. 
           
After several failed attempts at a comeback, the band managed to coerce Wilson into participating in a tour and record, resulting in 15 Big Ones (1976), both of which were wildly underwhelming, especially considering all of the “Brian is Back!” hype that surrounded both endeavors.  They reeked of nostalgia tour cheapness, and Wilson’s influence was barely felt, the proceedings mainly dominated by Mike Love.
           
However, the experience must have galvanized Wilson in some way, because soon after he began working on what would have been his first ever solo record.  It was to be called Brian Loves You, but soon, due to poor mental health again, among a multitude of factors, Wilson abandoned the project, despite recording almost sixteen full tracks, mostly performed by Wilson himself.  Then, coincidentally, the other Beach Boys realized they needed a new record to fill contractual obligations, so Carl Wilson unearthed the unreleased Brian songs and overdubbed additional instrumentation, along with the band’s idiosyncratic harmonies.  The result, Love You, is a warped, mostly brilliant oddity, and the last great record The Beach Boys ever released.
               
Beginning with “Let Us Go On This Way” and “Roller Skating Girl,” Love You starts off somewhat innocuously, but there are production touches that foreshadow what is to come later.  Both songs are bathed in synthesizers and heavily canned sounding drums, giving these songs a more modern sounding edge than most listeners were used to hearing from this band, at least since the progressive Pet Sounds.  Brian is also not heard in any capacity vocally until the final tag of “Roller Skating Girl” and when he enters, it’s a shock; gone is the beautiful falsetto that characterized his performances.  In its place is a gruff growl that is so rough there is almost no indication that this is the same person that sang “Don’t Worry Baby.”  After that opening one-two punch, the record becomes Wilson’s show, the other members providing attractive window dressing that keep things firmly in Beach Boys territory.
           
While he may have been in a difficult place, mentally and physically, at this time, Wilson shows throughout Love You that has hasn’t lost his signature naiveté and hopefulness.  “Johnny Carson” is probably the most well regarded song here, and it’s  status is well deserved.  The vocal arrangements are beautiful as usual, but it’s the lyrical content that really stands out, not because it’s a masterpiece of poetry, but due to its un-ironic take on Wilson’s love for the late night talk show host.  He goes into the minute details of his experience watching the show, from “[Carson’s] manly tone” and how when “it gets so boring he fills up the slack.” It’s a bizarre song, but in line with previous Wilson compositions that go into the minutiae of his life, such as “Busy Doin’ Nothin’.”  These childlike observations continue on “Solar System,” where Wilson basically names all the planets in order from closeness to the sun, couched in a classic Wilson melody with signature changes during the chorus, complete with another tastefully arranged group harmony.
           
Love You is not just focused on Wilson’s private musings, however.  In the middle of side two is a quintessential Wilson romantic suite, several beautiful love songs that highlight themes that he had been focused on since at least The Beach Boys Today, which Love You resembles structurally (both records linking their major ballads together on the second side of each).  “The Night Was So Young,” “I’ll Bet He’s Nice,” and “Let’s Put Our Hearts Together” are all fantastic songs, almost a perfect continuance of the mood set forth on Pet Sounds, full of romantic longing and hope. These songs represent the closest Love You ever gets to traditional Beach Boys material. However, with his new vocal delivery, songs that might have been viewed as sweet and innocent in earlier times now come across with a more desperate edge, the sound of a man clinging to his beliefs spite of what has happened to him.  These are the songs that end up truly defining Love You, highlighting conflicting emotions brewing inside the mind of a damaged man.
           
Love You is a standout in The Beach Boys canon, both in quality and idiosyncrasy.  There is absolutely nothing else like it in their, or any other band’s, discography (only the warped psychedelia of Smiley Smile comes close to the oddness on display here).  And, in spite of its seeming inaccessibility, this is one of the most outright enjoyable Beach Boys albums, being free of the hosannas surrounding Pet Sounds, which can make that album a bit of a daunting listen. Soon after this, the band completed its full on transformation into a nostalgia act, so Love You also represents a last stand for the original incarnation of The Beach Boys.  This is their last unfiltered explosion of creativity before the beginning of their endless summer, which makes Love You even more of an album to treasure. 





For Your Reconsideration: Rockpile - Seconds of Pleasure


Rockpile are one of the great should-have-beens in popular music.  Led by new wave stalwart Nick Lowe, who produced all of Elvis Costello’s early classics (as well as writing “What’s So Funny About Peace, Love, and Understanding?,” arguably Costello’s most famous tune), and retro genius Dave Edmunds, Rockpile set about combining a love of classic rock and roll with punk and new wave to create their own unique sound.  With Billy Bremner on lead guitar and Terry Williams on drums, their sound was muscular and tasteful, each member of the band being talented instrumentalists.  After providing backing on solo records by Lowe and Edmunds  (Labour of Lust, which contains the classic “Cruel To Be Kind,” and Repeat When Necessary, respectively), they decided to make an album under the Rockpile moniker.  The result, Seconds of Pleasure, is revelatory, combining the best qualities of Lowe’s and Edmunds’ individual styles into a unique and fun experience.
    

The dichotomy between the two is an essential part of that makes the record a success.  Lowe is the songwriter, and a strong one at that, witty, incisive, and economical both lyrically and instrumentally.  Edmunds is the historian, cherry picking deep cuts from rock and roll’s past. The record is split between the two of them, and the band helps bridge the gap between them with their brilliant playing, treating rock and roll and punk as if they were cut from the same cloth (which they are anyway).
    

Nick Lowe’s material on Seconds of Pleasure is some of his finest.  “Now And Always” plays like a Buddy Holly tune, with jangling guitars and great dual harmonies from Lowe and Edmunds.  However, Buddy Holly never sang about how “I close my eyes and count to ten, and wonder why I just don’t pack it in.”  Suicide, in other words.  This is one of Lowe’s great talents as a songwriter, couching bitter, sarcastic lyrics in sugar coated melodies that makes everything go down easier.  Elsewhere, “When I Write The Book” tells the tale of an aging bachelor who is losing his game, set to a book metaphor that his protégé Elvis Costello would later borrow for his own hit “Everyday I Write The Book.”  “Heart” is another highlight, this time sung by Billy Bremner, who holds his own vocally on this bouncy pop tune, while also laying down an excellent guitar solo drenched in Sun Records reverb.
    

Dave Edmunds, meanwhile, mines the past and comes up aces with his choices.  “If Sugar Was As Sweet As You,” originally by soul singer Joe Tex, is given a new wave sheen here, charging forward on endless momentum propelled by Terry Williams’ steady backbeat. He also provides Kip Anderson’s “A Knife And A Fork” with an slow burning intensity that belies its comical lyrics (this is perhaps the only song in rock history about obesity).  And, on album highlight “Wrong Again (Let’s Face It),” he takes a tune written by contemporaries Chris Difford and Glenn Tilbrook (of Squeeze fame) and completely makes it Rockpile’s own, strengthening its new wave nerviness with twangy guitars and pop harmonies.
    

Overall, Seconds of Pleasure stands as a testament to how talents on different wavelengths can come together to create something that highlights their individual qualities while also being a cohesive work that shows their strengths as a band.  However, having two such talents, and egos, led to internal tensions that resulted in Rockpile’s demise shortly after the release of this album.  But Seconds of Pleasure, along with Lowe’s and Edmunds’ contemporary solo releases, showcase a band that really could have become one of the greats had it lasted.






For Your Reconsideration: Harry Nilsson - The Point!


This week’s article focuses on one of the truly unique records of it's, or any for that matter, time.  How often do you listen to what is ostensibly a children’s album, complete with narration to propel its story, that holds up as a pristine pop record that transcends its inherently juvenile intentions?  For your reconsideration, here is Harry Nilsson’s The Point!.

The Point! tells the story of Oblio, a young boy from the land of Point, a land where all of its citizen’s heads come to a sharp point.  All except Oblio, that is, and to compensate he wears a pointy hat on his head to fit in. However, he is unfairly ostracized throughout his community, and later banished.  Along the way, he learns lessons about acceptance, and that even if you seemingly don’t have a point, you do.  Everyone does, in fact.  A valuable life lesson for children, couched in hippie ethos appropriate for its time.

What’s interesting about this story is that it came from a mind as fractured and iconoclastic as Harry Nilsson’s.  A notorious partier and heavy drinker, it would seem that Nilsson was not the ideal candidate to undertake such a project.  In fact, he came up with the concept for the record while on acid!  However, from the beginning, Nilsson’s work was couched in whimsy and simplicity, with songs like “Cuddly Toy” and “Daddy’s Song” steeped in  McCartney-esque music hall style, and even on his darker material, such as his classic “One,” later memorably covered by Three Dog Night.  Throw in his beautiful singing voice, which at its peak was one of the truly amazing instruments in music, and he was uniquely qualified to work on a record like The Point!

The songs written for the record, unlike a rock opera such as Tommy, or most concept albums of its ilk, are by no means tied explicitly to the story, which becomes the hidden strength of the album.  Instead, they illuminate the themes present without any sort of specific ties to the narrative surrounding it.  These songs stand up strongly on their own, and make this record possibly Nilsson’s most consistent listen, regardless of narration or concept. 

“Everything’s Got ‘Em” starts things off with a bright, lilting melody, and witty, incisive lyrics that help introduce the town of Point, and establish a foundation for the rest of the tale to take off from.  The citizens of Point are depicted as, to borrow an old hippie cliché, “straights” that are not especially welcome to change, if the line “that’s the way they wanted it, that’s the way it’s going to stay” is any indication.  It’s a catchy tune, and the way Nilsson sugarcoats his message with a bouncy melody and delicate instrumentation showcases a songwriter working at a peak.  “Me And My Arrow” follows, and is the highlight of this set.  It could almost be considered a lullaby, with its repeating lyrics that, while simple, work wonderfully, especially since they are matched to a wonderful rhythm track, which plays what can  be best described as a light funk shuffle.  It’s a masterpiece of simplicity, and a perfect pop song. 

The record continues along these lines, sticking with simple, unobtrusive arrangements, all the while interjected with Nilsson’s own charming narration, which is appropriately ramshackle (you can even hear him flipping through the pages of the script at certain points).  It concludes with another pop gem, “Are You Sleeping?,” and a final word from Nilsson that ties everything together.

One aspect of the record that is interesting in a more contemporary context is that, because of lean towards childlike simplicity and spare arrangements, The Point! could be seen as a forbear to modern indie pop, and twee pop in particular.  It wouldn’t be surprising to hear that Belle and Sebastian are fans of this record.
    
In addition, The Point! was made into an animated movie for television in 1971, and features the voice talents of Ringo Starr as the narrator.  The entire film can be watched on YouTube for free.
    
Overall, The Point! is a personal favorite from an artist whose unique talents have been somewhat overlooked over time.  Nilsson achieved a reasonable level of commercial success, in particular with Nilsson Schmilsson, which includes his schmaltz classic “Without You,” but drug and alcohol abuse eventually left him burnt out and in poor health, leading to his death in 1995. However, before all that, Harry Nilsson crafted something remarkable with The Point!, the rare album that transcends age and can be enjoyed equally, and in different ways, by everyone.





For Your Reconsideration: Geno Clark - Roadmaster


Of all the artists whose work fits the qualifications for this column, Gene Clark’s albums are the archetype, the inspiration for this endeavor.  His work is absolutely essential, and all but forgotten.  Honestly, any record from his slim solo output could have been spotlighted here.  However, for any curious reader, the best place to start would be the record that could be considered the most accessible, the one that represents an overview of all the artist’s strengths.  So, for your reconsideration, here is Gene Clark’s excellent Roadmaster.

First, a bit of background.  While his solo work may be woefully neglected, Clark will always have a place in rock history as one of the original members of The Byrds.  He was, during his short tenure, the group’s strongest songwriter, penning “I’ll Feel A Whole Lot Better,” “The World Turns All Around Her,” “She Don’t Care About Time,” and “Eight Miles High,” just to name a few. The problem was, at that time, as well as being the band’s best writer, he was also the only writer, which led to Clark making more money than the other members of the group.  This led to resentment by the others, particularly Roger McGuinn and David Crosby.  Add in a serious fear of flying, and Clark was out of the group by early 1966, just a year and three albums into the life of The Byrds.

After several excellent but overlooked albums, in particular his self-titled album (also referred to as White Light by fans), Clark entered the studio in 1972 to work on his next record.  These sessions were eventually aborted, but the eight songs composed during that period make up the bulk of what would eventually become Roadmaster.  By this point, Clark had been one of the originators of country-rock (although contemporary work by his former band and Bob Dylan, with Nashville Skyline, overshadowed his albums), and this album is definitely rooted in that style.  It’s also apparent that Clark had a true gift for this style.  All of the songs are fantastic and cover a wide range of emotions and styles within the confines of country-rock. 

“Full Circle Song,” which would be re-recorded a year later during the ill-fated Byrds reunion sessions, is a beautiful tune with great lyrics about how life is just an endless loop of cycles, or as Clark put it, “first you’re up, and then you’re down again.”  With it’s impassioned vocal delivery and tasteful instrumentation, it’s a true lost classic.  “In A Misty Morning” follows that song up nicely, a country ballad with impressive dynamic, starting quietly and building to a great ending, with Clark adding emotion to his vocal, but never resorting to histrionics.

Elsewhere, the title track tells the well-worn story of life on the road, and rolls along on a laid back, but definitely rocking, rhythm, and “She Don’t Care About Time” updates his classic Byrds track into a touching country ballad, giving the poetic lyrics a bit more gravity than in the original version.

As great as these songs are, tensions between the record label and Clark resulted in the sessions breaking down and the songs being shelved.  However, Clark’s producer, Jim Dickson, not wanting the album to gather dust, dug up three more tracks that had been recorded in 1970 and never used, and added them to the track listing.  One of those, “Here Tonight” has The Flying Burrito Brothers backing Clark on another classic country ballad, with his former Byrd member Chris Hillman adding great harmony vocals. The remaining two songs, while the album is consistently great throughout, provide its greatest moments, as they are both full Byrds reunions, recorded to help Clark’s flagging solo career, but, once again, problems with labels preventing their release before this record.  “She’s The Kind Of Girl” and “One In A Hundred” are simply fantastic songs, featuring Roger McGuinn’s 12-string Rickenbacker jangle and David Crosby’s plaintive harmonies in their full glory.  The vocal combination of Clark, McGuinn, and Crosby is just beautiful.  When Crosby’s voice cracks during the bridge of “One In A Hundred,” followed by McGuinn’s guitar jangling just as the line “hear the bells chime” kicks in, you know you’re listening to a great band.

Gene Clark was a man who should have had it better than he did.  He had all the talent in the world, but outside influences and bad luck always seemed to get the better of him.  He died in 1991, having never truly gotten the credit he deserved.  Luckily, Roadmaster is still here, as are at least four other records that represent a truly great artist.  Genius, even.




For Your Reconsidersation: Marshall Crenshaw - Marshall Crenshaw


Hello buffaBLOG readers.  This is Adam Putzer, guitar player for The Tins, and your very excited new contributor to this awesome site.  This is the initial edition of “For Your Reconsideration,” a look back at albums that have been perhaps unfairly maligned, unjustly forgotten, or just plain unusual, but all of which are ripe for rediscovery.  This includes artists both well-known and absolutely obscure as well.  I hope you enjoy going down this road as much as I will.


Marshall Crenshaw is perhaps best-known today for two reasons: co-writing the Gin Blossoms hit “’Til I Hear It From You,” and portraying Buddy Holly in the Richie Valens biopic La Bamba.  Interestingly, comparisons to Buddy Holly have dogged Crenshaw throughout the majority of his career, from his thick black rimmed glasses and close cropped hair, to his love of classic guitar pop. Crenshaw has always professed a deep love for Holly and doesn’t shy away from the comparison.  In fact, his self-titled debut album takes instrumental and lyrical cues from Holly, but it is no mere rip-off.  Coming out at a time when synthesizers and hairspray were fogging up the atmosphere of popular music, Crenshaw’s debut sounds like it could have been recorded at any time, including today, and is still a fantastic show of tight song craft and musicianship.

Crenshaw’s lyrics don’t tend to deviate from the love tropes consistent with classic pop material (girls are great, girls will break your heart, I don’t understand girls, etc.), but all are clever and sung with conviction.  The big hit here was "Someday Someway,” a song about misunderstanding in a relationship, based around a circular guitar riff and drum pattern that implies that these problems could continue foreve,  However, it doesn’t matter, because our narrator is so convinced of his love, he will stick it out and continue the pattern.  And Crenshaw’s vocal performance is flawless, sounding hopeful, yet naïve, in the face of what seems to be an impossible situation. Clever songwriting, indeed.

Other highlights include “Girls,” which expertly conveys his frustration with the opposite sex with its weary refrain of “girls, girls, girls,” and “Cynical Girl,” which adopts the use of a toy piano straight out of Buddy Holly’s “Everyday” to great effect.  Elsewhere, “The Usual Thing” transports rockabilly into the age of New Wave, and “Mary Anne” musically foreshadows many of Bruce Springsteen’s modern day rock anthems (take a listen to “We Take Care Of Our Own“ or “The Rising“ to see what I mean).  In addition, if you pick up the deluxe edition of the record, which is reviewed here, there are a couple of essential bonus tracks.  In fact, “You’re My Favorite Waste Of Time,” an early B-side, might be Crenshaw’s greatest song, a four-track recording based around drum machines and a circus organ that is absolutely brilliant, from the vocal melodies right down to the cheapness of the sound itself.  It certainly can be seen as a precursor to indie pop.

Bringing it all back home is a cover of Buddy Holly’s “Rave On.”  It’s nothing groundbreaking, but it is a loving and heartfelt performance by someone who is clearly a fan.  In fact, nothing on this album could necessarily be seen as breaking new ground.  But it is an undeniably enjoyable and meaningful work from an artist who should be highly regarded by people who like their guitar pop straight up, no bullshit.